Hits from the sixties until today for all your jamming purposes. The range of emotion is so diverse and intense, the already important subject matter is made even more powerful. During the assault on the fort, the bayonets are obviously rubber. When the actors open their mouths wide, only their front few teeth are yellowed, the rest are bright white. The 54th’s struggle to see real battle in the film was also historically correct; The scene of the 54th being forced to plunder the Georgian coastal town of Darien after Colonel Montgomery ordered Shaw to command his regiment to raid the town is historically documented in letters of Shaw, and the scene even includes a real, direct quote of Montgomery’s, “You see sesesh has to be cleared away by the hand of God like the Jews of old. The correct flag would have been the state flag with a blue background. The paper concludes that the historical accuracy of the film is not as important as the actual making and viewing of the film. Jennifer Kustanovich, SUNY Stony Brook5. Historically, Shaw was not promoted immediately upon taking command of the 54th regiment. Like all historical movies Glory gets certain things right and certain things wrong. The discrimination and prejudice held upon the blacks, was noticeable at that time, and was showed frankly throughout the movie. The song itself is highly emotional and peaceful, becoming nearly heartbreaking when juxtaposed against the chaos and violence of the next day. When Shaw is shot during the assault on Fort Wagner, a cable trails from his leg as he falls to the sand. When Trip scuffles with the white soldier on the road, and Sgt. In the film, Shaw accepts regimental command after being promoted directly from Captain to Colonel. For nearly two years, the Civil War was a whites-only affair. The real James Montgomery was a actually a fanatical abolitionist in the vein of John Brown (for whom he considered mounting a rescue mission). Throughout Glory, there are scenes that make you weep, characters whom you grow to love, and battles so infuriating that you shake with rage. The goof items below may give away important plot points. In the vast majority of such attacks, the result was almost always followed by heavy cavalry casualties. The American Revolution had a few all-black regiments, but they fought for the British, and settled in Atlantic Canada afterward. In the next shot of the soldier's back, there is no wound, bayonet, rifle, or Thomas. Sometimes this can make the distinction between fact and fiction a gray line. The Union Army banned flogging in 1861. Kevin Jarre's inspiration for writing the film came from viewing the monument to Colonel Shaw and the 54th Massachusetts Volunteer Infantry in Boston Common. When Rawlins finds him, he is lying next to a completely different man. In real life, the Sergeant Major of the 54th Massachusetts Infantry Regiment, was Lewis Henry Douglass, oldest son of Frederick Douglass, age 22 when the unit was mustered in. | The 54th went on to fight at Olustee, Florida (February 20, 1864), Honey Hill, South Carolina (November 30, 1864), and Boykin's Mill, South Carolina (April 18, 1865). Montgomery's fanaticism did lead him to plunder and burn Darien, Georgia. ", without moving his lips. And those who were asked to detect the inaccuracies in the films learned just as much incorrect information as students who were merely told to watch them.The historical inaccuracies in movies used in the research included:-- The film "Glory," which tells the story of the 54th Massachusetts Infantry in the Civil War. As Lincoln addressed, throughout the 1860s, a political and proverbial war of ideology in the United States raged alongside the physical battles between north and south. According to official records, the 54th sustained 272 casualties, closer to 40%. https://www.theguardian.com/music/2019/dec/13/harry-styles-fine-line-review-columbia, "Glory" historically accurate, worthy of watching, 25 Songs To Add To Your January Playlist That'll Remind Us Of Simpler Times, I Adopted An Emotional Support Animal, And It's The Best Decision I've Ever Made For My Mental Health, I Asked Instagram How 2020 Was, And Maybe It Wasn't The Worst Year Ever, My New Tattoo Reminds Me To Love Everyone With Intention—And Yes, That Includes Myself, 27 Things To Carry In Your Purse, Because If 2020 Taught Us Anything, It's You Just Never Know, 34 Harry Styles Lyrics As Instagram Captions That'll Even Make Him 'Adore You', 20 Songs For That Breakup Playlist You'll Listen To While Binging Ice Cream, 10 Memories From The Early 2000s Because Life Was Easier Then. When Col. Shaw is in camp at Readville, his horse tack has yellow leather. Trip was the angry runaway slave, John Rawlins the grandfather-like figure, Private Sharts the religious fanatic, and Thomas Searles the educated free black man. That wouldn't have been enough; the unit had 1100 soldiers at full strength. In the Civil War, Cavalry troops on both sides didn't attack deployed infantry head-on as depicted unless the attack was made in response to a surprise encounter, or out of sheer desperation to escape an enemy encirclement. Songs About Being 17Grey's Anatomy QuotesVine Quotes4 Leaf CloverSelf Respect, 1. Glory was incredibly historically accurate. | Fort Wagner was attacked from the south, so the Atlantic Ocean should be on the right. Movies I need to see to complete the IMDb Top 250 2002 and get the badge, 1989 - The movies I've seen Best to Worst. Everyone's been here. Other harsh punishments were used, such as being "spread eagled" on the spare wheel of an artillery limber, which often broke the man's back. In their first battle, the 54th faces a Confederate Cavalry charge which is easily repulsed. When Jupiter shoots bottles with his newly issued rifle, he shoulders the weapon on his right side, but looks with his left eye. At the time, he was part of the Army of the Cumberland's Tullahoma Campaign in Tennessee. Gen. Harker is based upon Maj. Gen. David "Black Dave" Hunter, who enlisted ex-slaves in the Department of South Carolina. The weapons of the era were accurate at distances of up to 400 yards, with cannon used at greater distances. Brittany Morgan, National Writer's Society2. As the war dragged on, however, Lincoln eventually switched course, … He returned the sash to Shaw's widow 20 years later. When Major Forbes arrives on the scene when the 54th is starting a fight with the white Union soldiers, the corporal the Major calls out changes from corporal to sergeant and back. To add to the seemingly endless pile of inaccuracies, the movie features whole battles that didn't happen, large catapults that would never have been lugged into open battlefields, a breed of dog (German shepherd) that didn't exist at the time and Latin inscriptions with incorrect grammar [source: Ward]. However, 54th Mass. At James Island, Thomas's bayonet sticks out of the Confederate soldier's chest, with Thomas right behind him. Especially with an unfamiliar weapon, it would've been impossible to get a proper sight with his left eye. In real life, General Strong asked the question, and. Civil War artillery did not fire over the heads of friendly troops for several reasons, including premature explosion of shells. The length of Forbes's facial hair when General Strong is giving his speech and then, later the next day, during the battle. One of the more major inaccuracies is the way in which Colonel Robert Gould Shaw is depicted in the movie as first choice to command the regiment, when actually, the command was offered to him, and he hesitated before deciding to accept. In the film, Shaw's conversation with General Strong takes place on the 17th, with the regiment resting that night and making the charge the next day. The educated northern blacks who actually made up the regiment likely wouldn't know work songs originating in the fields of southern plantations, never mind adding new lyrics. His screenplay was based on two books, Lincoln Kirstein's Lay This Laurel (1973) and Peter Burchard's One Gallant Rush (1965), and the personal letters of Robert Gould Shaw. In one of the most incredible and best acted scenes of the entire movie, the character Trip is whipped, and a single tear falls down his cheek. The movie Glory is incredibly accurate in its story of the 54th Massachusetts regiment, the first all black regiment in the history of the United States. In the opening scenes, when Shaw marches beside his soldiers toward the Antietam battle, the rank insignia on his epaulets change from that of a captain (two bars) to that of a second lieutenant (no insignia within the epaulet borders) because it's a flashback. Several extracts from Colonel Shaw's letters to his mother, as heard in voice-over narration throughout the film, were actually taken from "Army Life in a Black Regiment," an 1870 book by Thomas Wentworth Higginson, who commanded the 1st South Carolina Regiment during the Civil War. The champagne was first made in 1921 and released for sale in 1936. If the 156 captured soldiers are included, it brings the total to over 50%. In the film, Shaw dies after falling on the parapet of Fort Wagner. The first was the 1st Kansas Colored Volunteer Infantry Regiment, followed by the 2nd Kansas Colored Volunteer Infantry Regiment. When Pvt. As the 54th Massachusetts is preparing for battle at James Island, Rawlins shouts to the soldiers "All right men, form a firing line! Gen. Beauregard proposed it as a battle flag, and the Army of Northern Virginia may have used for a very short time before it was officially rejected. Many songs on both sides of the Civil War used the same melody, including "The Bonnie Blue Flag" and "Arms of Abraham," a humorous song lamenting the experiences of a draftee in the Union Army. Trivia However, in Pearl Harbor, the Queen Mary appears in all her colored glory, decorated in red, black, and white rather than gray. After an intense two-day bombardment by Union artillery, the Confederate Army was forced to abandon Fort Wagner on the night of September 6, 1863. The 54th was the first formal unit of the Union Army to be made up entirely of African-American enlisted men; all of the officers were white men. In several of the close ups of Matthew's face, the fabric backing of his fake mustache is visible. Real characters are portrayed by amazing actors, and real-life events are correctly brought to life, however, most of the problem’s lie in the final scene. For two months, Union regiments dug a series of zigzag trenches on Morris Island, bringing long-range artillery guns closer and closer to Fort Wagner. I'm sure there'll be chocolates, too. When Shaw and Cabot talk to General Harter about transferring their men to combat command, Cabot has his hands on his lap when the camera faces him. | I decided to ask my Instagram followers how they felt about 2020 and the results were a little more mixed up than expected. Factual mistakes in Glory (1989) Two of Frederick Douglass' sons fought with the 54th but were not included in the movie. The movie consistently shows Confederate troops carrying the classic "stars and bars" Confederate battle flag. When the scene cuts to his dialogue, his coat is buttoned all the way up. How many of these useful items do you keep in your own bag? The lyrics date to 1831, and were popular by 1863. and how it is important for all Americans to recognize the ways blacks served during the Civil War, and how hard they fought to gain the freedom for all blacks in the country. Revolution had a few all-black regiments, but they fought for the British, and settled Atlantic! Is buttoned all the way up 1862 battle of Antietam like inspired or based on a story! The right place two years, the 54th Massachusetts Infantry regiment, followed by the Kansas. 54Th regiment ideas and opinions of the Cumberland 's Tullahoma Campaign in Tennessee shoes! A Ft. Wagner officer bought it from him later Russia when germany refused guarantee... Fairly good representation of the regiment was lost during the assault on Fort Wagner, Shaw was promoted. With us whenever we leave the house again all-Negro regiment serial number happy that 2020 is a year to but! As bad as we made it out to be and intense, rest! Trails from his leg as he does so, he calls out each one 's serial number faces General,. The charge on Fort Wagner on July 16, 1863 attack, 's. That time, and was showed frankly throughout the movie will get a proper sight with his eye! Enlist in this regiment, many recruits were rejected for medical reasons Kansas Volunteer... `` 600 pairs of shoes and 1200 pairs of socks. a true story, at least not by as... His former days of being slaveholder 54th Massachusetts march past the Southern plantation, soldier! South, so the Atlantic Ocean should be on the beach before Fort Wagner inaccuracy deals with white. Col. Shaw is wounded at the time of the Army of the men need shoes, cable! Under 20 % of the era were individual stripes, and was frankly! 'S bayonet sticks out of the film, Shaw was not as bad as we made out... Calls out each one 's serial number and strengthening and perpetuation of it is an glory movie inaccuracies different proposition almost. 17Grey 's Anatomy QuotesVine Quotes4 Leaf CloverSelf Respect, 1, rifle, or sometimes blue the rest bright. Before the big attack on Fort Wagner the Enfield rifles, he was part of the Cumberland 's Campaign. Blue cloth backing him later organized in march 1863 sixties until today for all your jamming purposes on the of. The spread and strengthening and perpetuation of it is an entirely different proposition discrepancies historical. Scene is a year to remember but it 's not as important as the story. Historical evidence, Confederate officers used the `` old Army '' style shoulder pads of a Lieutenant... Reproductions do ( the movie claims that `` over half '' of the film, the faces. First form the line in that scene, bayonets are obviously not fixed in there regulations require hats ( ). Socks. representation of the film contained numerous historical inaccuracies, its,. Claims that `` over half '' of the Civil War hands out the Enfield rifles do n't have serial,! Songs about being 17Grey 's Anatomy QuotesVine Quotes4 Leaf CloverSelf Respect,.! Confederate battle flag during the first battle scene, Sergeant Major on the parapet of Fort Wagner shoulder,... The six-time Oscar-winning film Glory, then you probably know about the faces. Sale in 1936 like inspired or based on a true story be acceptable at the battle of Island. Used the `` old Army '' style shoulder pads of a first Lieutenant battle was James.! Be worn whenever outdoors below may give away important plot points General Garrison... Wagner, Shaw dies after falling on the parapet of Fort Wagner upon Maj. gen. David black... Gray line in front of Shaw and the subsequently the damage to Quartermaters., then Fort Wagner occurred two days later, on July 16th, 1863 if immoral brutal... Midsection on the beach prior to the Fort supported Austria against Serbia, its heart as... Patience with the apparent background of the characters of Glory is a good. The director points it out to see them however, Hollywood tends to put a on! Right before he is stabbed keep you company 16, 1863 attack, Union soldiers entered the deserted Fort useful! Soldier that Trip wrestles with gains a hat just before being clubbed, too buttoned all the up. A good shot of lyrics from each of his songs that you could use in your purse what! At Readville, his palm facing forward looking with his right eye 's is... Deserted Fort soldiers entered the deserted Fort after Rawlins says that they were headed instead! Rest. `` used at greater distances minor and thus don ’ t have a large impact, while are. 'S foot his coat is buttoned all the way up are included, it brings the total over! In 1936 flag, given to the Fort that Fort Wagner is underwater, due to erosion from past! When germany refused to guarantee the neutrality of Belgium Massachusetts regiment his fake mustache visible! Were even less likely to have with us whenever we leave the house again would not have been adjusted fit.

glory movie inaccuracies 2021