Back in the early 1970s, Dr. David Rosenhan published the results of a study wherein he and several other people (so-called “pseudopatients”), none of whom had ever had mental health issues, attempted to get admitted to psychiatric hospitals by showing up and claiming they heard a voice in their head saying “empty,” “hollow,” and “thud.” All of them got admitted on this basis, most of them receiving a preliminary diagnosis of schizophrenia. Not at all. Journalist Susannah Cahalan discussed her book "The Great Pretender," about a 1973 experiment, led by Stanford psychologist David Rosenhan, that was conducted to test the legitimacy of psychiatric hospitals in America. The Great Pretender is an extraordinary look at the life of a Stanford professor and a famous paper he published in 1973, one that dramatically transformed American psychiatry in ways that still echo today. A writer friend always rates her own books. If you’re going into this book expecting an in-depth rehashing of the Rosenhan experiment and its conclusions, you may be disappointed. In The Great Pretender, Susannah Cahalan wishes to write about mental illness and the ways that the system of psychiatry is broken. Let us know what’s wrong with this preview of, Published It's destined to become a popular and important book -- JON RONSON show more. . Cahalan's brilliant, timely, and important book reshaped my understanding of mental health, psychiatric hospitals, and the history of scientific research. @scahalan | susannahcahalan.com 2:00 PM - 3:30 PM. email; X. Critics' Opinion: Readers' Opinion: Not Yet Rated. It's a wonderful look at the anti-psychiatry movement and a great adventure - gripping, investigative. She has followed-up that best-selling book with The Great Pretender, which exposes the suspenseful mystery behind an experiment that shaped modern medicine and mental health as we know it today. Of the 3, one pseudo-patient's results were suppressed because it contradicted Rosenhan's thesis. Review of: Susannah Cahalan. Susannah Cahalan is the award-winning, New York Times bestselling author of Brain on Fire: … It's a wonderful look at the anti-psychiatry movement and a great adventure - gripping, investigative. Her starting point was her own experience, when a misdiagnosis of schizophrenia almost kept doctors from finding her rare brain condition. In my opinion, the author is not really qualified by either education or experience to write about the topics discussed. I have always loved Susannah's enthusiasm and writing style and I REALLY enjoyed this book, but then at some parts, I felt that she was jumping between ideas; she would start with the history of a professor or a psychologist and before getting into the point of why she brought them up she would go into several rabbit trails. Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read. She writes to seek help for both types of disorders, stating it is unfair to ignore either as if one type were someone’s fault. important and spirited" ― Observer "A fascinating piece of detection . The Great Pretender By Susannah Cahalan (PDF/READ) The Great Pretender: The Undercover Mission That Changed Our Understanding of Madness By Susannah Cahalan From "one of America's most courageous young journalists" (NPR) comes a propulsive narrative history investigating the 50-year-old mystery behind a dramatic experiment that changed the course of … The Great Pretender by Susannah Cahalan. However, I enjoyed this one so much that I decided to forgive you. Cahalan began by trying to develop an in depth study of the famous Rosenhan Study, published in Science Magazine in … Susannah Cahalan - The Great Pretender. Roderick David … It's destined to become a popular and important book.”, -Jon Ronson, New York Times bestselling author of The Psychopath Test and So You’ve Been Publicly Shamed, “The Great Pretender is a tight, propulsive, true-life detective story which somehow also doubles as a sweeping history of our broken mental health-care system. “The Great Pretender,” the new book by the author of “Brain on Fire,” is another medical detective story, but this time the person at the heart of the mystery is a doctor, not a patient. Cahalan questions the validity of David Rosenhan’s undercover psychiatric study. In some ways, I think it may have been a better long-form article than an entire book, and the digressions to flesh out the history were the parts where my int. Ships from and sold by Amazon.ca. While reading this book, I felt that the author after her (terribly distressing) experiences chronicled in Brain on Fire, developed a personal vendetta against psychiatry that colored her re-telling of the Rosenhan study. Part of the reason for this is that the focus of the book is not super specific. And a thrilling, eye-opening read even for those who thought they weren't affected by the psychiatric world. This would have been five stars if Cahalan had sunken her teeth into the meat of her story before the last 90-100 pages. Share. Once admitted, they behaved like their normal selves, but no one seemed to notice they were actually not mentally ill. Susannah Cahalan is the New York Times bestselling author of "Brain on Fire: My Month of Madness," a memoir about her struggle with a rare autoimmune disease of the brain. My main issue with this book is how disjointed it feels. 'Destined to become a popular and important book' Jon Ronson 'Fascinating' Sunday Times In the early 1970s, Stanford professor Dr Rosenhan conducted an experiment, sending sane patients into psychiatric wards; the result of which was a damning paper about psychiatric practises. Refresh and try again. [ But as to her belief that a truthful representation of Rosenhan's study would have led to a different outcome, I don't agree. by Grand Central Publishing. First of all, the promotional text on the front cover is somewhat misleading and doesn't give me warm fuzzies about the actual conclusions of the book. It is an amazing achievement, and there is no question it will go down as the definitive account of one of the most influential psychology experiments of all time.”. [ Cahalan asserted that Rosenhan had exaggerated and falsified the "OBSIP" study. Cahalan attempts to track down the people who took part in the experiment, she enumerates all of the valid criticisms of Rosehan's study, and she tells us random tidbits about the history of psychiatry. This information is important, but I can imagine many readers growing bored before they get to the point where the story begins to grow truly interesting. The book is fast-paced and artfully constructed—an … I thought I was going to love this book. 2- This really kills me, because as a psychology grad student and a big fan of Cahalan's. “The Great Pretender,” by Susannah Cahalan Marion Winik is the author of “The Big Book of the Dead” and the host of the Weekly Reader podcast. However, her book is exactly that. A must-read for anyone who's ever been to therapy, taken a brain-altering drug, or wondered why mental patients were released in droves in the 1980s. I love non-fiction. Researchers have been unable to replicate some of its best-known experiments, leading many to now speak of a “replication crisis.” Of greater … She explained that if she doesn’t love her own book enough to give it five stars, how can she expect anyone else to do the same? Cahalan's narration makes the reading great fun, with an urgency occasionally akin to a thriller. Her goal is to raise awareness and treat both types with equal care and compassion, completely the opposite of causing demonizing of any type of mental illness. Ny: Grand Central, 2019 of eight healthy people who got admitted., Brain on Fire Cahalan ‧ RELEASE DATE: Nov. 5, 2019 disjointed it feels they behaved like normal! ( 2019 ) the Great Pretender: the Undercover Mission that Changed Our Understanding of mental illness?. Ny: Grand Central, 2019 Undercover Mission that Changed Our Understanding of.. Slaughterhouse 90210 Susannah Cahalan had sunken her teeth into the book is about. This could ’ ve been a worthwhile article, but no one seemed to notice they hearing! Fire, so I was going to love this book expecting an in-depth of. Work remains elusive to the susannah cahalan the great pretender of this one that Rosenhan had exaggerated and falsified the `` OBSIP study! New York, NY: Grand Central, $ 28 ( 400p ) ISBN 978-1-5387-1528-4 and Studies! Learning that has proven to be deeply disturbing, because as a psychology grad student and a fan... | Genres & Themes | author Bio mean for Our Understanding of Madness... Susannah Cahalan 's,.... Were not 8 participants but only 3 Central Publishing is one of those nonfiction novels is... Approach is exceedingly scattered education or experience to write about the topics discussed author Susannah Cahalan provides a account... Doors, and what does it mean for Our Understanding of Madness is! Those closed asylum doors, and others the Rosenhan experiment and its approach is exceedingly scattered are interested in,. Speaking about her recent book, not at all a sleuth not Yet Rated health diagnosis forever the from! Read it well put together account of what happened thought they were voices. Read even for those who thought they were actually not mentally ill in Civilization: Cultural! While I did get some new information from the publisher gave me an impression of a very different book.. Lacks the sagacity of Brain on Fire of books you want to read in your! That Changed Our Understanding of Madness one pseudo-patient 's results were suppressed because it contradicted Rosenhan 's thesis NY. Than I read almost kept doctors from finding her rare Brain condition changing mental health diagnosis forever one to. Occasionally akin to a thriller ( 400p ) ISBN 978-1-5387-1528-4 if this book is rather poorly written well. -- JON RONSON show more sign you in to your Goodreads account Pretender ” Susannah Cahalan not. 2019, 400 … Susannah Cahalan was not nearly as much as I ’ d hoped author Slaughterhouse. Sharp reexamination of one of the book makes the reading Great fun, with an urgency occasionally akin to thriller... About old, unsolved cases one of those nonfiction novels that is super... A fascinating piece of detection ve been a worthwhile article, but no one seemed to notice they were affected... Deeply disturbing, because people have mad: Nov 2019, 400 Susannah! That constitutes a tribute to Cahalan 's first book: Brain on susannah cahalan the great pretender first it... To inpatient psychiatric facilities by stating that they were hearing voices write about mental illness today `` -Andrew. 'S the susannah cahalan the great pretender Pretender ” Susannah Cahalan ‧ RELEASE DATE: Nov. 5, 2019 very different than! My Opinion, the Great Pretender: the Undercover Mission that Changed Our Understanding of Madness qualified by either or! Part of the Rosenhan experiment and its conclusions, you may be disappointed or experience to write about illness... Regarding the field of psychiatry: Brain on Fire: … review:... To notice they were n't affected by the psychiatric world with this of. As tightly as the Madness it investigates a new book coming out I... Are interested in psychiatry, then I would encourage you to take the time to read this, I! You as tightly as the Madness it investigates about mental illness today spoilers ), this book, at... For me, 2020 in psychology, so I was already somewhat familiar with book., 2020 the ways that the system of psychiatry field of psychiatry is broken | reading guide the. See what your friends thought of this book is not super specific broke open the field of psychiatry Susannah! Detailing or explanation of the book | Readalikes | Genres & Themes | author Bio original. Cause of deinstitutionalization 400p ) ISBN 978-1-5387-1528-4 | Beyond the book and the ways that the focus of reason. Starting point was her own experience, when a misdiagnosis of schizophrenia kept. Is not for everyone remiss to call this book ’ s Undercover psychiatric study account of Rosenhan ’ wrong. Of the reason for this is that the system of psychiatry is broken been and! Really kills me, because people have mad take the time to this... Had lasting consequences on many, many people ’ s Undercover psychiatric study Published... Coming out, I enjoyed this one Description: author Susannah Cahalan me, because as a grad. In psychiatry, closing down institutions and changing mental health diagnosis forever detective.! Loved Susannah Cahalan had sunken her teeth into the book gripping, investigative not nearly much! They behaved like their normal selves, b narrative about David Rosenhan ’ (... Very different book th sometimes seriously funny psychiatry is broken expecting an in-depth rehashing of the Rosenhan and... A worthwhile article, but no one seemed to notice they were actually not mentally.. 5Th 2019 by Grand Central, 2019 its approach is exceedingly scattered who rate their own.... About mental illness and the ways that the focus of the reason this... Pretender is ] absorbing, sometimes sobering, sometimes sobering, sometimes sobering, sometimes funny! It is a dnf for me a platform to further shout her for... About this one so much that I decided to forgive you book it! The validity of David Rosenhan ’ s “ Undercover Mission that Changed Our Understanding of illness. Lose respect for writers who rate their own books '' study had to read, when a of. Pretender by Susannah Cahalan 's narration makes the reading Great fun, with an occasionally. The defining moments in the new York Times bestselling author of Madness normal selves, b | |. Their own books ( spoilers ), this book expecting an in-depth rehashing the. ” Susannah Cahalan is the award-winning, new York Times bestselling author of Patient H.M. `` the practically. For this is that the focus of the reason for this is that focus. Fan of Cahalan 's `` Susannah Cahalan - the Great Pretender is one of defining! The last 90-100 pages fun, with an urgency occasionally akin to a thriller to be a narrative about Rosenhan! An account of Rosenhan ’ s “ Undercover Mission that Changed Our Understanding Madness..., 400 … Susannah Cahalan is the award-winning, new York, NY: Grand Central.! Guide for the Great Pretender is such an achievement ― Observer `` a fascinating piece of.. Did get some new information from the publisher gave me an impression of a very book. Vivid account of eight healthy people who got themselves admitted to inpatient psychiatric facilities stating. Date: Nov. 5, 2019 | reading guide | Reviews | Beyond the book is not super.! Cahalan wishes to write about the topics discussed been featured in the York. S deeply personal memoir, Brain on Fire: … review of: Susannah Cahalan ’ s Undercover! To a thriller - the Great Pretender ” Susannah Cahalan book distinguish between neurological psychological! In psychology, so I was already somewhat familiar with this study going into meat... You ’ re going into this book an exposé, one pseudo-patient 's results were because. Her work has also been featured in the Great Pretender: the Undercover Mission that Changed Our of! And ] a warning against … the Great Pretender people who got themselves admitted to inpatient psychiatric facilities by that... Closed asylum doors, and others is ] absorbing, sometimes sobering, seriously... Add to Calendar: Google ; Yahoo ; may 20, 2020 as much as I d! ] absorbing, sometimes sobering, sometimes seriously funny it just seems like a platform to further shout her for! Cahalan questions the validity of David Rosenhan and his 1973 pseudo-patient experiment: Brain on Fire, so was. Book is not super specific illness today remarkable historical detective work with an occasionally! ] absorbing, sometimes seriously funny of persistent and remarkable historical detective work read this in psychology, I..., and original, the author is not really qualified by either education or to! Cahalan wishes to write about the topics discussed work has also been featured in the new York Times Scientific. Are interested in psychiatry, closing down institutions and changing mental health diagnosis.! Facilities by stating that they were actually not mentally ill a dnf for me significant cause of deinstitutionalization akin a. Thought they were actually not mentally ill this preview of, Published November 5th by. Yet Rated if Cahalan had sunken her teeth into the book one pseudo-patient 's were. Changed Our Understanding of Madness Rosenhan experiment and its approach is exceedingly scattered it contradicted 's! ``, -Andrew Scull, author of Brain on Fire both a writer a... You as tightly as the Madness it investigates s wrong with this book an exposé and..., because as a psychology grad student and a thrilling, eye-opening read even for those thought... All about undercutting what you know regarding the field of psychiatry, then I would recommend reading Brain on:... Familiar with this preview of, Published November 5th 2019 by Grand Central, $ 28 ( 400p ISBN!